CCP Interference Looms Large Over Taiwan’s January 2024 Elections

Frank Fang
By Frank Fang
January 2, 2024International
share
CCP Interference Looms Large Over Taiwan’s January 2024 Elections
(L–R) Lai Ching-te, presidential candidate from the ruling Democratic Progressive Party (DPP), Hou Yu-ih, presidential candidate from the main opposition Kuomintang (KMT), and Ko Wen-je, presidential candidate from the opposition Taiwan People's Party (TPP), pose for a picture during a debate in Taipei, Taiwan, on Dec. 30, 2023. (Pei Chen/Pool/AFP via Getty Images)

News Analysis

Taiwan’s voters are heading to the polls in less than two weeks to elect a new government for the next four years. The free and fair elections are overshadowed by China’s influence campaigns trying to swing the election results in its favor.

On Jan. 13, some 19.5 million Taiwanese voters are expected to elect a new president and members of the 113-seat national legislature. Three of the biggest parties in Taiwan—the ruling Democratic Progressive Party (DPP), the main opposition Kuomintang Party (KMT), and the Taiwan People’s Party (TPP), a relatively new party founded in 2019—have each fielded a ticket for president and vice president.

Leading in most local polls is the DPP ticket—current vice president Lai Ching-te and his running mate Hsiao Bi-khim, who stepped down as Taiwan’s de-facto ambassador to the United States in November. In second place is the KMT presidential candidate Hou Yu-ih, the current mayor of New Taipei City, and his running mate Jaw Shaw-kong, a local media personality. Former Taipei Mayor Ko Wen-je is the TPP candidate, who has picked fellow party member, Legislator Wu Hsin-ying, as his running mate.

The Chinese Communist Party (CCP), which intends to take over Taiwan through peaceful means or war, has long viewed the DPP with hostility, seeing the party and its agenda as roadblocks to its path to “reunification” with the self-ruled island. Meanwhile, the communist regime favors KMT candidates, who see Beijing as less threatening to the island’s national security.

Wang Juntao, a U.S.-based Chinese democracy activist and scholar, told The Epoch Times that two factors will decide the outcome of the elections—voters’ perspective on China–Taiwan relations and domestic policies relating to the economy. He pointed out that the overwhelming majority of Taiwanese youth do not want the island to become part of China.

On Dec. 31, CCP leader Xi Jinping reaffirmed his intention to seize Taiwan while delivering his 2024 New Year address, saying that China and Taiwan “will surely be reunified” and “all Chinese on both sides of the Taiwan Strait should be bound by a common sense of purpose and share in the glory of the rejuvenation of the Chinese nation.”

Theresa Fallon, director of the Centre for Russia Europe Asia Studies, said Xi’s remarks were “carefully calibrated” for the Taiwan elections on Jan. 13, noticing how he “struck a stronger tone than he did last year,” according to her post on X, formerly Twitter.

Taiwan President Tsai Ing-wen, who is also the DPP chairwoman, responded to media inquiries about Xi’s remarks after delivering her New Year address on Jan. 1. Ms. Tsai said the decision to any future cross-strait relationship must be based on “democratic principles” and the “common will” of the Taiwanese people.

Ms. Tsai also pointed out China’s efforts to interfere in the island’s elections started in 1996 when the island held its first direct presidential election. She expressed hope that people in Taiwan are alert about false information while being confident that voters will make a smart choice.

“Xi Jinping is a murderous dictator and a pathetic thug who wants to force the freedom-loving people of #Taiwan to live under his brutal Communist oppression,” wrote Rep. Carlos Gimenez (R-Fla.) on X in response to Xi’s New Year remarks. “We’re about to enter 2024, but dictator Xi is trying to send the world into the Stone Age.”

NTD Photo
Taiwan presidential candidate Lai Ching-te (L) and his running mate Hsiao Bi-khim (R), from the ruling Democratic Progressive Party (DPP), gesture in front of supporters after they registered running for the 2024 presidential elections in Taipei, Taiwan, on Nov. 21, 2023. (Sam Yeh/AFP via Getty Images)

China’s Interference

During a presidential debate on Dec. 30, all three candidates pledged to uphold Taiwan’s current status quo. Mr. Lai also said he would continue the current president’s policies toward China and the United States.

“On so-called Taiwan independence, Taiwan’s basic position is that Taiwan’s sovereignty and independence belong to its 23 million people, not the People’s Republic of China,” Mr. Lai said during the debate.

Mr. Hou said that he opposes both Taiwanese independence and the “one country, two systems,” a political system that Beijing imposed on Hong Kong after the former British colony was handed back to China in 1997.

Meanwhile, Mr. Ko emphasized that maintaining Taiwan’s current status quo was “the only option.”

Despite some similarities in how the three candidates stand on cross-strait relations, there are signs that China would prefer Mr. Hou to win the presidential race. For example, on Dec. 22, an online media reporter surnamed Lin was detained for allegedly publishing fake polls showing the KMT ticket in the lead. Mr. Lin allegedly did so at the behest of CCP’s provincial committee in southern China’s Fujian Province.

Lee Yeau-tran, an adjunct professor at the Graduate Institute of Development Studies of Taiwan’s National Chengchi University, told The Epoch Times that China has taken to YouTube, Facebook, and Twitter in an attempt to influence the outcomes of the Jan. 13 elections. Other influence tactics included offering funded China trips to low-level Taiwanese government officials and Taiwanese temple groups, Mr. Lee added.

According to a new report from New York-based research firm Graphika, an influence operation involving actors posing as Taiwanese users used Facebook, YouTube, and TikTok to promote the KMT while criticizing other candidates, including Mr. Lai and Mr. Ko.

“The content closely tracked Taiwan’s news cycle, quickly leveraging domestic news developments, such as controversies surrounding an egg shortage and the alleged drugging of toddlers at a kindergarten, to portray the KMT’s opponents as incompetent and corrupt,” the report said.

On Dec. 29, local prosecutors in Taiwan’s central city of Taichung announced an investigation against eight borough chiefs, 28 Taiwanese voters, and the head of a local travel agency for potential violations of the island’s anti-infiltration law. The chiefs and voters allegedly paid below-the-market prices for trips to the southern Chinese city of Xiamen, during which they met with the city’s CCP officials. Six of the borough chiefs have since been released on bail, and two others are restricted to their residence.

NTD Photo
Ko Wen-je (R), chairman of the Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) and presidential candidate, and his TPP running mate Cynthia Wu wave after they registered for the upcoming 2024 presidential elections at the Central Elections Commission in Taipei, Taiwan, on Nov. 24, 2023. (Sam Yeh/AFP via Getty Images)

Yuan Hongbing, a former law professor at China’s Beijing University, told The Epoch Times that he had learned from sources that the Taiwan Affairs Offices at all levels of the Chinese regime’s political system had been given an order to “privately pressure” Taiwanese businessmen in their regions to support political candidates that Beijing has approved of in the upcoming January elections.

According to data released by the Taiwan government last month, about 473,000 Taiwanese nationals worked overseas in 2022, with China accounting for the majority, or 37.5 percent of the total.

Ultimately, China has different goals behind its efforts to influence the outcomes of Taiwan’s elections, according to Mr. Wang and Mr. Lee.

“Making Taiwan chaotic can reduce [Chinese] people’s desire for wanting to live in a democracy like Taiwan while making [the CCP’s] rule look more legitimate,” Mr. Wang said.

Mr. Lee said China’s goal behind its efforts to meddle in the elections is to “make Taiwan accept the arrangement of ‘one China, two systems’ … it is about ‘subduing an enemy without fighting.’”

Responses

The outcomes of the legislative elections on Jan. 13 are equally important since they will decide if the party that wins the presidency can also enjoy a majority in the national legislature.

Nathan Batto, an associate research fellow at Taiwan’s Academia Sinica, predicted in early December that the DPP will likely lose its legislative majority after the elections.

“Looking at the most recent polling, it looks to me like the most likely outcomes are either a hung parliament in which the TPP holds the balance of power or an outright KMT majority,” Mr. Batto said during an event hosted by the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS).

A hung parliament means not a single party secures the necessary 57 seats to enjoy a majority in the national legislature.

Mr. Batto added, “If it is a hung parliament and the TPP holds the balance of power, and Ko Wen-je maintains strong control over his party, he will be the one who controls the balance of power in the legislature.”

At an event held by the Brookings Institute on Dec. 14, Kharis Templeman, a research fellow at Stanford University’s Hoover Institution, said: “It’s actually quite likely that no one party is going to control both branches of government.

“I think the conventional wisdom is that even if Lai Ching-te wins, he’s not gonna have a governing majority in the legislature. And if Hou Yu-ih wins, he’s also unlikely to have a KMT majority at least,” Mr. Templeman added.

NTD Photo
KMT’s presidential candidate Hou Yu-ih and his vice presidential candidate Chao Shao-kang wave at the journalists before registering the candidacy of the presidential election in Taipei, Taiwan, on Nov. 24, 2023. (Annabelle Chih/Getty Images)

If the DPP wins the presidency and takes the legislative majority, Mr. Lee said the CCP might react by taking forceful measures against the island.

“If Lai and Hsiao become elected and the KMT and the TPP hold the legislative majority, [China] will try to manipulate [KMT and TPP] legislators so that they can interfere with the DPP’s agenda at the legislature,” Mr. Lee said.

On the contrary, if either Mr. Hou or Mr. Ko becomes the president, Mr. Lee said that Beijing would try to force the new president to adopt policies favorable to China, such as having the island sign the Cross-Strait Service Trade Agreement, a bilateral trade deal that was shelved after student protests in Taiwan in 2014.

Washington will also react differently to different election outcomes, according to Mr. Lee.

“If Lai and Hsiao become elected, the relationship between Taiwan and the United States will continue to be like the close cooperation between the United States and free worlds during Tsai’s presidency,” Mr. Lee said.

“In other words, it is the so-called new cold war where free democracies take on Russia, North Korea, and Iran, which are allied with the CCP as the axis of evil.”

If the former Taipei mayor becomes the president, Washington will ask him to follow Ms. Tsai’s foreign policies on China, Mr. Lee added.

If Mr. Hou becomes Taiwan’s next president, Mr. Lee said Taiwan–U.S. relationship might take a step back because of his vice president, Mr. Jaw, who co-founded a pro-unification party in 1993. According to a report from the Washington-based Global Taiwan Institute, Mr. Jaw is a “firebrand political commentator” known for “intemperate anti-American and pro-Chinese views.”

“Under such circumstances, the United States will definitely have a lot of doubts about Taiwan, and the bilateral exchange on high-tech and military technology will be greatly impacted,” Mr. Lee said.

Luo Ya contributed to this report.

From The Epoch Times