Father of Christian Woman Killed in Isis Captivity Disgusted to Find Out Pompeo Stripped of ‘Hostage Freedom Award’

Father of Christian Woman Killed in Isis Captivity Disgusted to Find Out Pompeo Stripped of ‘Hostage Freedom Award’
US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo speaks during a press conference after meeting with Kim Jong Un's right-hand man Kim Yong Chol in New York on May 31, 2018.
NTD Photo

Carl Mueller’s daughter, Kayla Mueller, was a young Christian woman from Prescott, Arizona, who “was drawn to alleviate the suffering of Syrian refugees,” according to her family. After graduating college in 2009, Kayla worked with humanitarian aid groups in India, Israel and Palestinian territories. Her plan to work in Africa changed when civil war broke out in Syria, and in 2012 Kayla moved to southern Turkey, where she worked with Support to Life and the Danish Refugee Council to aid those fleeing the conflict.

Kayla was kidnapped on Aug. 4, 2013 by ISIS militants, who ambushed her vehicle as she left a Doctors Without Borders hospital in Aleppo. For 18 months, she was held hostage and reportedly abused personally by ISIS leader Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi. Refusing to convert to Islam during her imprisonment, those who were imprisoned with her claimed that she clung to her Christian faith, even defending it to the notoriously brutal “Jihadi John.”

ISIS claimed that Kayla was killed during coalition airstrikes in early 2015, at the age of 26. Though it confirmed her death, the U.S. government reached no official conclusion regarding the cause of it, and her parents remain unsure of her ultimate fate.

Carl and his wife, Marsha, traveled to Washington, D.C., earlier in the week to attend the James W. Foley Legacy Foundation Awards Dinner, named for the journalist who was beheaded by ISIS in 2014. They also met with Pompeo, who was originally slated to receive an award from the organization for his work to release American hostages worldwide. The foundation later rescinded the award because of pressure from media groups that paid up to $50,000 for a table, according to knowledgeable sources who spoke with The Washington Examiner.

The foundation’s executive director, Margaux Ewen, nevertheless maintained in a Friday statement that such claims were “mischaracterized,” and that the award was revoked because of the Trump administration’s response to the murder of Saudi Arabian journalist Jamal Khashoggi.

Ewen’s statement said, in part, that “while it is accurate that our foundation intended to present our hostage freedom award to Secretary Pompeo until [Jan. 11], we ultimately decided we could not present the award as planned due to the dramatic change in circumstances when the administration did not press for genuine accountability from the Saudi government for the brutal murder of journalist Jamal Khashoggi.”

US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo speaks at a United Nations Security Council meeting
US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo speaks at a United Nations Security Council meeting on Venezuela, Jan. 26, 2019, at the United Nations in New York. (JOHANNES EISELE/AFP/Getty Images)

“In addition to advocating for the safe return of American hostages abroad, the protection of free speech and promotion of journalists’ safety is a key pillar of our foundation and this award would have been in conflict with that key principle,” Ewen added.

Whatever the reason for the foundation’s decision, Mueller was so angered by the Freedom Awards Dinner that he “literally got up and left” after he “suffered through [keynote speaker Christiane Amanpour’s] little speech.” He believes Pompeo’s loss of the award “was all political” and driven by the liberal media’s hatred for President Donald Trump.

“It is sad that this kind of thing has worked its way into society—the hate for Republicans, mostly the hatred for Donald Trump,” Mueller said. “But it’s sad that it dictates to a fine foundation that’s trying to do good work and good things, but yet unfortunately bows to these journalists. They said they would boycott the event if Mr. Pompeo got the award. And the only reason I can see they would do that is because of their hatred of Donald Trump.”

NTD Photo
President Donald Trump, second left, speaks as Jim Mattis, secretary of defense, from right, Mike Pompeo, secretary of state, Vice President Mike Pence and Jens Stoltenberg, secretary general of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO), listen during a meeting in the Cabinet Room of the White House in Washington, DC on May 17, 2018. (Andrew Harrer-Pool/Getty Images)

Mueller asserted that he and his wife “probably wouldn’t have attended [the dinner] had we known that they succumbed to the pressure of the left media. So is the Foley Foundation now run by these people? This is the first indication that that might be true.”

“It’s typical when a foundation gets as large as the Foley Foundation, and it’s very sad that it cowers down and bows down to the pressure from the left media. I find that very disturbing,” Mueller lamented, adding, “We’ve known the Foleys for a long time. I admire and respect [foundation president] Diane Foley, and she has done so much. But given this kind of thought and rhetoric, I hope that a Republican reporter never gets taken. Because are they are going to support him? It’s a ludicrous question, but that’s what comes to mind.”

Though he maintains that Brett McGurk, the Obama-era diplomat who was the ultimate recipient of the award, is “a wonderful man” who deserves recognition, Mueller was disappointed by the Obama administration’s attitude toward his daughter’s ordeal.

“I’ll tell you a little story about [former Secretary of State] John Kerry and the Obama administration,” Mueller said. “We were communicating 18 months with ISIS to save our daughter. And when President Obama finally decided to meet with us—finally agreed to meet with us after a second request—we were leaving the White House and John Kerry was walking in. If it hadn’t been for [former Democratic Indiana Sen.] Joe Donnelly grabbing him by the arm and dragging him over to us, he would have never met with us. He never attempted to meet with us. He never requested a meeting with us.”

NTD Photo
President Barack Obama at the headquarters of the CIA in Langley, Va., on April 13, 2016. Also pictured are (L-R) Vice President Joe Biden, Secretary of State John Kerry, CIA Director John Brennan, and National Security Adviser Susan Rice. (Win McNamee/Getty Images)

Mueller contrasted such behavior with the current administration and secretary of state. “I have to stand up for the Trump administration and Mr. Pompeo in regards to the hostage situation and the hostage families,” Mueller maintained, noting “they reached out, brought us to D.C., we met personally with Secretary Pompeo.” Mueller mentioned how they were just one of many hostage families invited to meet with Pompeo the past week.

“We have many questions that we still need to answer that the previous administration has blocked,” Mueller continued. “Our story is starting to come out because obviously we’re coming out of the closet in a big way. We told Secretary Pompeo at our private meeting with the other families that we truly believe that if this current administration was in when Kayla was captured, she would be home. We truly believe that.”

In remarks delivered Tuesday in Washington, D.C., to families of Americans held captive abroad, Pompeo expressed the personal interest he takes in securing their release. “For those of you’ve had a chance to come visit my office—a handful of you did it today—you would have seen on the edge of my desk a Bible that I keep open every day to remind me of what matters most in our life—God and family, doing what’s right, protecting the weakest,” Pompeo said.

After recounting the biblical story of the apostle Peter being miraculously saved from prison, Pompeo soberly admitted that such outcomes are not always forthcoming. Shortly before mentioning Kayla and others by name, he said, “Sometimes, tragically, our efforts fail, or they don’t produce results as quickly as they deserve. And I want you all to know I am not here today to instill in you any false hope. Sometimes our best simply is not enough. And we mourn all the men and women that have been wrongly detained and who have been lost to us. I met with some of their families today as well.”

“What I can do today for each of you,” he added, “is to make my personal commitment known, to talk to you about what it is we’re doing and will continue to do every day – our very best every day to deliver every wrongfully detained American home.”

by Mike Brest and Jon Brown

Follow Mike Brest on Twitter

Follow Jon Brown on Twitter

ntd newsletter icon
Sign up for NTD Daily
What you need to know, summarized in one email.
Stay informed with accurate news you can trust.
By registering for the newsletter, you agree to the Privacy Policy.