Judge Dismisses Brett Favre Defamation Suit, Saying Shannon Sharpe Used Hyperbole Over Welfare Money

Judge Dismisses Brett Favre Defamation Suit, Saying Shannon Sharpe Used Hyperbole Over Welfare Money
Former NFL quarterback Brett Farve is inducted into the Ring of Honor during a halftime ceremony during the game between the Green Bay Packers and the Dallas Cowboys at Lambeau Field in Green Bay, Wis., on Oct. 16, 2016. (Hannah Foslien/Getty Images)

JACKSON, Miss.—A federal judge on Monday dismissed Brett Favre’s defamation lawsuit against fellow retired NFL player Shannon Sharpe, ruling that Mr. Sharpe used constitutionally protected speech on a sports broadcast when he criticized Mr. Favre’s connection to a welfare misspending case in Mississippi.

U.S. District Judge Keith Starrett ruled that Mr. Sharpe, a former tight end, was using “rhetorical hyperbole” in saying on air that Mr. Favre was “taking from the underserved,” that the former quarterback “stole money from people that really needed that money” and that someone would have to be a sorry person “to steal from the lowest of the low.”

Mr. Favre sued Mr. Sharpe in February, saying that the fellow Pro Football Hall of Fame member made “egregiously false” statements about him on the Fox Sports talk show “Skip and Shannon: Undisputed.” The case was moved to federal court in March, and Mr. Sharpe left the sports show in June.

Discussion of Mississippi welfare spending on “Undisputed” took place after extensive news coverage about allegations of Mississippi’s largest public corruption case.

Mississippi Auditor Shad White has said that from 2016 to 2019, the Mississippi Department of Human Services misspent more than $77 million from the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program—money that was intended to help some of the poorest people in the U.S.

Prosecutors have said the department gave money to nonprofit organizations that spent it on projects favored by wealthy and well-connected people, such as a $5 million volleyball facility at the University of Southern Mississippi, a project for which Mr. Favre agreed to raise money.

Judge Starrett wrote in his ruling Monday that Mr. Sharpe’s references to “taking” and “stole” referred to diverting TANF money “for purposes other than helping the underprivileged.”

“Similarly, Mr. Sharpe’s use of the words ‘people that really needed that money,’ the ‘lowest of the low,’ and ‘the underserved,’ again are examples of protected, colorful speech referring to needy families in Mississippi,” the judge wrote.

“Here, no reasonable person listening to the Broadcast would think that Mr. Favre actually went into the homes of poor people and took their money—that he committed the crime of theft/larceny against any particular poor person in Mississippi,” Judge Starrett wrote.

Monday night on X, formerly known as Twitter, Mr. Sharpe noted the dismissal of the lawsuit and thanked his legal team for handling the case.

Shannon Sharpe
Former NFL football player and current sports analyst Shannon Sharpe poses at a special screening of the Netflix documentary film “The Redeem Team,” at Netflix Tudum Theater in Los Angeles on Sept. 22, 2022. (Chris Pizzello/AP Photo)

The Associated Press sent an email to Mr. Favre’s attorney Michael Shemper late Monday to seek comment about the dismissal of the lawsuit.

Mr. Favre is not facing criminal charges, but he is among more than three dozen people or businesses the state is suing to try to recover misspent welfare money.

In addition to suing Mr. Sharpe, Mr. Favre filed defamation lawsuits earlier this year against White, the auditor, and sportscaster Pat McAfee, who is a former NFL punter. Mr. Favre ended his lawsuit against McAfee in May, after McAfee apologized for on-air statements that Favre had been “stealing from poor people in Mississippi.” Favre’s lawsuit against White is still pending.

Mr. Favre has repaid the $1.1 million he received for speaking fees from a nonprofit group that spent TANF money with approval from the Mississippi Department of Human Services. White said Favre never showed up to give the speeches.

In December, the department made a new demand of up to $5 million against Mr. Favre and a university sports foundation, saying welfare money was improperly used to pay for a volleyball arena at Mr. Favre’s alma mater, the University of Southern Mississippi.

Mr. Favre’s daughter started playing volleyball at the university in 2017. Filings in the state’s civil lawsuit show text message exchanges between Mr. Favre and others about directing money to the volleyball facility from a nonprofit organization that had Department of Human Services contracts.

By Emily Wagster Pettus

ntd newsletter icon
Sign up for NTD Daily
What you need to know, summarized in one email.
Stay informed with accurate news you can trust.
By registering for the newsletter, you agree to the Privacy Policy.