Mother of Man Charged in Missing Brothers Case Speaks Out

Mother of Man Charged in Missing Brothers Case Speaks Out
In this undated booking photo provided by the Caldwell County Detention Center in Missouri shows Garland "Joey" Nelson. (Caldwell County Detention Center via AP)

KINGSTON—The mother of a Missouri farmer charged with tampering with a truck used by two missing Wisconsin brothers said they came to the farm to look at cattle but that she can’t see her son being involved in their deaths.

Tomme Feil told The Kansas City Star that the two men—Nicholas Diemel, 35, and his 24-year-old brother Justin—came to look at calves owned by the family.

Justin Diemel and Nicholas Diemel
35-year-old Nicholas Diemel (R), and his 24-year-old brother, Justin Diemel. (Clifton County Missouri Sheriff)

Feil said she has no idea why her son, Garland Nelson, would have moved their vehicle.

“I wish I knew the truth,” Feil said. “But I don’t.”

The brothers were reported missing July 21 and are presumed dead. Law enforcement found human remains on the farm that have not yet been identified, Clinton County Sheriff Larry Fish said.

Missing person Missouri
missing poster for Justin Diemel (L) and Nicholas Diemel. (Clinton County Missouri Sheriff’s Department/File Photo via AP)

Nelson is accused of driving the rental truck from the farm near Braymer that the brothers visited during a business trip for their cattle operation in Wisconsin. The truck was found abandoned and running.

Nelson admitted to moving the brothers’ truck from his mother’s farm to a commuter lot in Holt, according to court documents.

He appeared in court Thursday and will remain in jail without bond. The Kansas City Star reported Nelson said he has an attorney, who was not in the courtroom.

Feil told the newspaper that she returned home July 21 from a trip to Branson with the rest of the family to find police speaking to her son. She said she wouldn’t know if he got mixed up in something he shouldn’t have, but she’s hoping for “it all to go away.”

Sheriff Larry Fish
Clinton County Sheriff Larry Fish (L), with Callaway County Sheriff Jerry Galloway, speaks about human remains that have not been positively identified, found on July 30 in a farm in Braymer in Polo, Mo. (Rich Sugg/The Kansas City Star via AP)

She said her son is hardworking and cares about family.

Feil said church friends and neighbors in the small town have shown her support but that she has received harassment and threats as police investigate the brothers’ deaths. She said she turned off all her social media accounts.

Feil is staying in her home but can’t venture out to do farm work because of the active investigation. Law enforcement are doing her chores and feeding her cattle.

“I have nothing to be guilty for,” Feil said. “But a lot of times you’re guilty by association. This is not my character, not my family’s.”

Previous Investigations

Nelson has been the subject of previous investigations, including a federal one, Fish said.

In 2015, when Nelson was 21 years old, he pleaded guilty to a cattle fraud scheme that resulted in losses of nearly $300,000 for the victims, according to a news release from the U.S. Attorney’s Office in the Western District of Missouri.

Nelson’s three-part fraud scheme included loan fraud, livestock sales and insurance fraud, the attorney’s office said.

A year later, Nelson was sentenced to two years in federal prison without parole and ordered to pay $262,450 to the victims.

The CNN Wire contributed to this report.

ntd newsletter icon
Sign up for NTD Daily
What you need to know, summarized in one email.
Stay informed with accurate news you can trust.
By registering for the newsletter, you agree to the Privacy Policy.