Name: 69 Percent of NYC Crime Cases Dismissed After New Justice Reform Law: Manhattan Institute
Uploaded: 2023-01-20T04:24:31.000Z
Description: New York City prosecutors are seeing more and more of their cases dismissed without going to trial after the state passed new court evidence requirements, according to a new study.

Jack Bradley is a Washington correspondent for NTD News based in Washington, D.C. Jack previously anchored "NTD Newsroom" and worked as an assistant producer for the show. 

Jack Bradley

NTD Plus

News

News with integrity, from the U.S. and around the world. Focused reports and analyses that shed light on major issues the world deserves to know. NTD Evening News airs daily at 6 p.m. ET.

NTD Evening News

China’s Broken Promises Loom Over New Trade Deals

David Lam is a national correspondent based in California and a part-time anchor for "NTD Tonight." Before joining NTD he was a financial analyst.

David Lam

Californians React as Trump Calls for Gas Tax Suspension

Arleen Richards is NTD's legal correspondent based at the network's global headquarters in New York City, where she covers all major legal stories. Arleen holds a Doctor of Law (J.D.).


Arleen Richards

Federal Agencies Announce ‘Summer Surge’ of Law Enforcement into DC Ahead of 250th Anniversary

Christina Corona is a California-based reporter for NTD News. She primarily covers California news, politics, and entertainment.  

Christina Corona

Trump Administration Reports Zero Border Releases

Arian Pasdar is an international correspondent for NTD News based in South America. His reporting focuses on immigration and key events in Latin America.

Arian Pasdar

US to Host 1st Ever World Cup Final Halftime Show, Featuring Shakira, Madonna

Savannah Pointer is a politics reporter for The Epoch Times. She can be reached at savannah.pointer@epochtimes.us

Savannah Hulsey Pointer

Jason Perry is an Army veteran and NTD's National Security Correspondent based at the network's global headquarters in New York City. Jason primarily covers border security, national defense, foreign wars, and veterans' issues.

Jason Perry

Health News

Texas Children's Hospital to Open First-Ever Detransition Clinic Under Deal With DOJ

Sam Wang is a Washington correspondent for NTD News based in Washington, D.C. Sam covers politics on Capitol Hill, and U.S.-China relations. 

Sam Wang

Citizens Honor Police for Their Service and Sacrifice

Cary Dunst is the news anchor for NTD Evening News. He is also the co-host of NTD Good Morning.


Cary Dunst

Trump ‘Projecting American Influence and Leadership’ on Iran Issue in Beijing: China Expert

Chris Bob is a reporter for NTD and a host of "Profiles of Service." He is also a small business owner. Chris graduated from Union College with a concentration in politics and religion in Russia and the former Soviet Union.

Chris Bob

Senate Panel Advances Crypto Regulation Bill

Jason Blair is a national correspondent for NTD News based in California. 

Jason Blair

Lawmakers Weigh ‘Sanctuary’ Polices After Woman’s Death in Virginia

NTD Evening News Full Broadcast (May 15)

NTD Evening News Full Broadcast (May 14)

NTD Evening News Full Broadcast (May 13)

NTD Evening News Full Broadcast (May 12)

NTD Evening News Full Broadcast (May 11)

Don Ma is an anchor and senior business correspondent based at the network's global headquarters in New York City. Don is the anchor and producer of NTD's "Business Matters," which airs weekdays at 4:30 pm ET.

Don Ma

NTD Evening News Full Broadcast (May 10)

NTD Evening News Full Broadcast (May 9)

NTD Evening News Full Broadcast (May 8)

NTD Evening News Full Broadcast (May 7)

NTD Evening News Full Broadcast (May 6)

NTD Newsroom comprises teams of reporters, editors, and producers assigned to cover breaking news and other stories.


NTD Newsroom

Fast, compelling, first-hand news from China. China in Focus airs Monday–Friday at 8 p.m. ET.

China in Focus

China Sends Warships to Pacific Drill as Tensions With Japan Rise

Reuters is a news agency owned by Thomson Reuters. It employs around 2,500 journalists and 600 photojournalists in about 200 locations worldwide writing in 16 languages.

Reuters

We present news that is truthful and based on facts, outside of the political fog. Instead of focusing on the negative things happening around us, our mission is to give our viewers a good morning with empathetic and uplifting stories. Our aim is to provide an antidote to negativity by shining a light on the best side of people. We speak to inspiring people who positively impact communities, pursue topics that represent our common human values, and will never miss an opportunity to bring you heartwarming stories.

NTD Good Morning

2 US Embassy Personnel Assigned to Cartel Case Killed in Car Accident

The Associated Press is an American not-for-profit news agency headquartered in New York City. 

The Associated Press

US News

Gunman Kills 8 Children, Including 7 of His Own, in Louisiana Mass Shooting

Flora Hua is a reporter based at NTD's global headquarters in New York City, where she covers China news, U.S.-China relations, and human rights issues. Flora primarily contributes to NTD's "China in Focus."  

Flora Hua

Trump: Seized Iranian Ship May Have ‘A Gift From China’

Joseph Lord is a congressional reporter for The Epoch Times.


Joseph Lord

Aldgra Fredly is a freelance writer covering U.S. and Asia Pacific news for The Epoch Times.

Aldgra Fredly

Former NYC Mayor Rudy Giuliani Hospitalized in Critical Condition: Spokesman

Wildfires Across Georgia and Florida Have Destroyed Nearly 50 Homes and Are Forcing Evacuations

News you can trust from the U.S. and around the world. Critical information and insight. We cover the stories that others don’t. NTD News Today airs Monday–Friday at 11 a.m. ET.

NTD News Today

US Warns of China Hacks via Routers, Smart Devices

Juliet Song is an international correspondent exclusively covering China news for NTD. She primarily contributes to NTD's "China in Focus," covering U.S.-China relations, the Chinese regime's human rights abuses, and domestic unrest inside China.

Juliet Song

2 Americans Among Suspected Communist Rebels Killed in Clashes With Troops, Philippine Officials Say

Ryan Morgan is a reporter for The Epoch Times focusing on military and foreign affairs. He was previously a news writer for NTD. 


Ryan Morgan

Mari Otsu is NTD's White House correspondent based in Washington. 

Mari Otsu

World News

Middle East

Iran

3 US Warships Fend Off Iranian Attacks, Trump Says Ceasefire Still Holds

3 Dead in Suspected Hantavirus Outbreak on Cruise Ship in Atlantic Ocean: WHO

New York City prosecutors are seeing more and more of their cases dismissed without going to trial after the state passed new court evidence requirements, according to a new study.

In 2019, New York changed its <a href="https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/CPL/A245" target="_blank" rel="noopener">laws</a> governing how prosecutors are supposed to share evidence with criminal defendants in criminal procedures, accelerating the pace at which prosecutors are supposed to grant discovery to the accused. Discovery is the legal term for the formal process by which either party in a court case is allowed to see the evidence that will be presented in a trial.

The new law, which went into effect in January 2020, makes discovery automatic rather than requiring defense attorneys to request evidence. The law also sets a strict time frame of 45 days for prosecutors to turn over evidence to defense teams after a defendant's arraignment. The law further requires the inclusion witness information and grand jury testimony as part of their evidence disclosures, even if witnesses are not planning to testify in the trial. Another portion of the law states that prosecutors must disclose all potentially discoverable material it possesses at the time it is offering a plea deal to a defendant.

According to a <a href="https://www.manhattan-institute.org/how-new-york-discovery-law-destabilizes-criminal-justice-system" target="_blank" rel="noopener">report</a> by the Manhattan Institute, the number of cases that prosecutors have had to dismiss has risen from about 44.3 percent under the old discovery laws to about 69.5 percent in 2021.

The report showed that under the previous laws, 44.3 percent of cases ended in dismissal while 45 percent ended with the defendant making a plea bargain, 8 percent being held for a grand jury or transferred to the New York Supreme Court, and 2.5 percent of cases ending in other dispositions such as trial verdicts. By mid-October of 2021 (when their data ends), the Manhattan Institute found that the number of guilty pleas had shrunk from about 45 percent of cases in 2019 to 21.3 percent.

"Discovery is fundamental to a fair trial because it is impossible for defendants to make informed plea-bargain decisions if they do not know the strength of the evidence that prosecutors have against them. However, New York’s 2019 discovery statute ... has crippled the state’s criminal justice system with an untenable compliance burden," the Manhattan Institute wrote.

Misdemeanor cases saw an even greater number of dismissals. In 2019, 49 percent of misdemeanor cases ended in dismissals while 47 percent ended in guilty pleas. By mid-October of 2021, 82 percent of misdemeanor cases ended in dismissals and 15.5 percent ended in guilty pleas.
<h2>Institute Attributes Spike in Crime Rates to Discovery Laws</h2>
While prosecutors may be dropping cases simply because they are running out of time to turn over all required evidence, the Manhattan Institute argued that witness disclosure provisions in the new discovery laws are also contributing to the growing number of cases that get dismissed.

Because the prosecutors must disclose grand jury and witness information early on, including for witnesses not planning to testify, the Manhattan Institute reasoned that potential witnesses are "understandably, by all available measures and reporting, are choosing not to testify in increasing numbers of cases."

"The statute, therefore, has correlated with a devastating rise in crime and a drop in arrests," the institute added.

Since the discovery laws went into effect, New York City adult felony arrests fell by 14 percent between 2019 and 2021, while shootings rose by 102 percent and murders rose by over 51 percent, according to the institute. Felony drug arrests dropped by 48 percent while drug overdose deaths rose by almost 80 percent.
<h2>Some Defense Attorneys Didn't Read Discovery Materials In Allotted Time</h2>
The Manhattan Institute argued that the new discovery laws place more burden on prosecutors than defense attorneys. The think tank said that prosecutors are unable to build their cases and prepare for trial while they are busy "chasing paper" to meet the discovery requirements. At the same time, the institute noted many defense attorneys didn't even review the evidence prosecutors provided to them within the first month.

According to interview sources that spoke with the Manhattan Institute, in the first year after the new discovery laws were implemented, defense attorneys were failing to access discovery packages within their 30-day windows in 60 percent of cases.

While the institute claimed many defense attorneys didn't look at the discovery materials provided to them under these new laws, Legal Aid Society outright challenged this claim as a "lie." In a comment to the New York Post, a spokesperson for the organization <a href="https://nypost.com/2023/01/19/new-study-shows-how-ny-law-puts-bad-guys-back-on-streets/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">said</a>, "Our team downloads discovery and disseminates evidence typically within 24 to 48 hours. The report’s author is either a liar or is so credulous and unconcerned with verifying facts that she should not be taken seriously."

Incoming president of the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (NYSACDL), Yung-Mi Lee, didn't necessarily challenge the allegation that 60 percent of defense attorneys didn't open the discovery files within 30 days, but told the New York Post that this finding may be the result of some technological challenges. Lee said defense attorneys are still working through the technical challenges of how they receive evidence.

"But I have to say, discovery reform has been incredibly eye-opening and extremely helpful,” Lee added.
<h2>'Unfillable' Vacancies in Prosecutors Offices</h2>
The institute further argued that the increased clerical burden with the new discovery laws has caused many prosecutors to quit. The institute said Manhattan and Brooklyn each lost about a fifth of their prosecutors between the spring of 2021 and the spring of 2022.

The institute conducted an informal survey in October, finding that several district attorney's offices throughout the state had recorded attrition rates of up to 40 percent, and "unfillable vacancies."

District attorneys "are losing seasoned prosecutors and are forced to try to recruit new ones right out of law school," the institute wrote.

The new law appears to have even exhausted a high-profile prosecutor who favors criminal justice reform. When Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg took office in January 2022, he ordered his team <a href="https://www.ntd.com/manhattan-district-attorney-addresses-publics-concerns_738266.html">to dismiss many cases</a> involving trespassing, resisting arrest, and even called for armed robbery cases not involving firearms to be treated as misdemeanors. But Bragg has also complained about the discovery laws.

In March, Bragg said “we’ve experienced record attrition, as our ADAs burned out and sought less demanding jobs for more money," the New York Post <a href="https://nypost.com/2022/06/25/more-nyc-prosecutors-quit-because-of-reform-laws/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">reported</a>.
<h2>Proponent Says Reforms Are an 'Unmitigated Positive'</h2>
Jennifer Van Ort, executive director of NYSACDL, <a href="https://nysacdl.org/news/628787/NYSACDL-Objection-to-Manhattan-Institute-Report-on-Discovery-Reform.htm" target="_blank" rel="noopener">said</a> the organization "strongly objects to the ultra-conservative Manhattan Institute's flawed and biased conclusions that NYS Discovery reform has been anything but an unmitigated positive for New York's citizenry."

Van Ort said the reforms were "long overdue" in a state with "one of the nation's highest wrongful conviction rates." She said the reforms help prevent prosecutors from slowly releasing evidence to defense attorneys in a way that disadvantages their clients and leaves them "unable to confront the evidence against them."

NEW YORK CITY

Videos

Politics

04_Top Stories

New York

Latest Clips

criminal justice reform

Alvin Bragg

Latest and breaking news, documentaries, movies, and lifestyle content on NTD+.
 
Empower your knowledge and elevate your spirit with NTD+, your go-to destination for truthful news, insightful documentaries, and captivating lifestyle content that enriches your life.