Name: Lawsuit Using Environmental Law Against Biden Immigration Policies Can Proceed: Judge
Uploaded: 2022-09-06T19:29:16.000Z
Description: A District of Columbia federal judge did not dismiss a lawsuit that relies on the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) to challenge Biden administration actions on immigration, marking an unmatched if still early success for the use of environmental law against illegal immigration.

NTD Newsroom comprises teams of reporters, editors, and producers assigned to cover breaking news and other stories.


NTD Newsroom

NTD Plus

News

News you can trust from the U.S. and around the world. Critical information and insight. We cover the stories that others don’t. NTD News Today airs Monday–Friday at 11 a.m. ET.

NTD News Today

EU Accuses TikTok of Failing Child Protections

Former Sen. Joe Manchin Reenters Politics Aged 78

Court Allows Tennessee’s Pro-GOP Electoral Map

Iran Threatens UK Bases Used by US

Stefania Cox is an NTD News anchor and national correspondent based at the network's global headquarters in New York City. Stefania anchors "NTD Newsroom," and co-anchors "NTD News Today" weekdays at 10:00 am ET.

Stefania Cox

Trump Is Doing What He Has a Moral and Legal Right to Do: Economist on Anti-Forced Labor Tariffs

Daniel Monaghan is a reporter for NTD News covering culture, social issues, and education. He holds a BA in Political Science and Government.

Daniel Monaghan

Hiring Veterans: Turning Military Skills Into Civilian Careers

Fiona Ji is a reporter based at NTD's global headquarters in New York City, where she covers local news.

Fiona Ji

DC Candlelight Vigil Commemorates Victims of CCP's Persecution of Falun Gong

Juliette Fairley is a freelance reporter for NTD and The Epoch Times and a graduate of Columbia University’s Graduate School of Journalism. Born in Chateauroux, France, and raised outside of Lackland Air Force Base in Texas, Juliette is a well-adjusted military brat. She has written for many publications across the country. Send Juliette story ideas at JulietteFairley@gmail.com

Juliette Fairley

Weather

Flood Emergency Brings National Guard to West Virginia

New US Tariffs on Canada Target Risks from Wildfire Management: Economist

Treasury Blocks Federal Payments to Deceased People

NTD News Today Full Broadcast (July 24)

Paul Greaney is an NTD news anchor and producer. Since joining the company in 2018, he has anchored the station’s flagship Evening News broadcast, launched the NTD Business show, and produced documentary reports on pointed issues. 

The highlight of Paul’s time in the field was his coverage of the Hong Kong pro-democracy protests in 2019.

Paul Greaney

NTD News Today Full Broadcast (July 22)

NTD News Today Full Broadcast (July 21)

NTD News Today Full Broadcast (July 20)

NTD News Today Full Broadcast (July 17)

NTD News Today Full Broadcast (July 16)

NTD News Today Full Broadcast (July 15)

Kevin Hogan is an NTD News data reporter and national correspondent based at the network's global headquarters in New York City. Kevin covers breaking news, as well as U.S. and global current events. He conveys the news through data visualizations and investigates pressing issues.

Kevin Hogan

NTD News Today Full Broadcast (July 14)

NTD News Today Full Broadcast (July 13)

NTD News Today Full Broadcast (July 10)

Tom Gantert is a reporter for The Epoch Times.

Tom Gantert

Melina Wisecup is NTD's congressional correspondent based in Washington, covering Capitol Hill and campaign politics.

Melina Wisecup

US News

Politics

Executive Branch

Trump Uses Recent Speeches to Warn Americans of Resurging Communism

Juliet Song is an international correspondent exclusively covering China news for NTD. She primarily contributes to NTD's "China in Focus," covering U.S.-China relations, the Chinese regime's human rights abuses, and domestic unrest inside China.

Juliet Song

Shows

Fast, compelling, first-hand news from China. China in Focus airs Monday–Friday at 9:30 p.m. ET.

China in Focus

2.8 Million People in China Evacuated Amid Typhoon Bavi

Joseph Lord is a congressional reporter for The Epoch Times.


Joseph Lord

Congress

House Passes Legislation to Make Daylight Saving Time Permanent

NTD Films

NTD+ Movies

The Unrestricted War

The Associated Press is an American not-for-profit news agency headquartered in New York City. 

The Associated Press

Sen. Lindsey Graham Likely Died After Aorta Tear, Medical Examiner Says

Mary Man is a writer for NTD. She has traveled around the world covering China, international news, and arts and culture.

Mary Man

China News

China Floods: Thousands at Risk After Multiple Dams Collapse in Guangxi

Jackson Richman is a Washington correspondent for The Epoch Times. In addition to Washington politics, he covers the intersection of politics and sports/sports and culture. He previously was a writer at Mediaite and Washington correspondent at Jewish News Syndicate. His writing has also appeared in The Washington Examiner. He is an alum of George Washington University.

Jackson Richman

House Passes Defense Policy Bill That Attaches SAVE America Act

Ryan Morgan is a reporter for The Epoch Times focusing on military and foreign affairs. He was previously a news writer for NTD. 


Ryan Morgan

World News

Middle East

Iran

US, Iran Launch New Strikes; Trump Warns Ceasefire May Collapse

Bringing you the latest videos, livestreams, and premieres.


NTD Video

Label

Live

NTD+ Live

Trump Signs Executive Order at White House (June 29)

Jack Phillips is a breaking news reporter with 15 years experience who started as a local New York City reporter. Having joined The Epoch Times' news team in 2009, Jack was born and raised near Modesto in California's Central Valley. 

Jack Phillips

Mari Otsu is NTD's White House correspondent based in Washington. 

Mari Otsu

Leavitt Previews Trump's Thursday Election Speech

A District of Columbia federal judge did not dismiss a lawsuit that relies on the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) to challenge Biden administration actions on immigration, marking an unmatched if still early success for the use of environmental law against illegal immigration.

District Court Judge Trevor McFadden, a Trump appointee, ruled on Aug. 11 (<a href="https://cis.org/sites/default/files/2022-08/Order-on-Motion-to-Dismiss.pdf">pdf</a>) that his court has jurisdiction over the case.

The lawsuit pits immigration reformers, environmentalists, and ranchers against the Department of Homeland Security, the Department of Justice, and the Department of State.

"I think people would support the efforts to stop ignoring the massive environmental consequences of immigration," said Julie Axelrod, director of litigation for the Center for Immigration Studies, in an Aug. 30 interview with The Epoch Times.

Axelrod filed an amended complaint (<a href="https://cis.org/sites/default/files/2022-02/Filed-Amended-Complaint.pdf">pdf</a>) on behalf of the plaintiffs. A previous NEPA lawsuit from the Center was rejected for lack of standing, first by the Southern District of California and then by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.

One plaintiff in the D.C. lawsuit, cattle rancher Chance Smith, lives near Douglas, Arizona, in an area his family has called home since the 19th century.

The shift from Trump to Biden "caused the number of crossers he personally sees crossing the ranch to increase to eight or nine times [what] it was before," the complaint states.

Smith says those border jumpers degrade the land, leaving behind trash or even buried drugs and guns.

"He [Smith] needs to bring a pistol at all times, even though he would prefer not to. However, he knows he is under threat of trouble from cartel members at all times when the border is not under control by law enforcement," the suit continues.
<h2>NEPA and the Border</h2>
Signed into law by former President Richard Nixon, NEPA was a milestone in protecting nature from damage by the federal government.

"If NEPA should apply to any government policy, it should be to federal policies that induce population growth," the Center’s complaint argues.

The suit cites the direct effects of unchecked illegal immigration on the border, as experienced by Smith and others.

It also refers to broader negative impacts of immigration-driven population growth, including urban sprawl, farmland loss, reduced biodiversity, and strain on water resources.

The government’s motion to dismiss (<a href="https://cis.org/sites/default/files/2022-02/Memorandum-Motion%20to-Dismiss.pdf">pdf</a>) the lawsuit asserts that the plaintiffs lack standing. It claims the complaint hinges on "highly speculative and generalized grievances related to the effects of population increases," adding that none of the alleged harms can be linked to changes by the Biden administration.

It also argues that many actions the lawsuit challenges fall under agency discretion.

McFadden ruled that Smith, one of the plaintiffs, has standing, stating that the injuries he claims are not excessively speculative "if they can be proven true or false later in the litigation."

He dismissed just two of the plaintiffs’ nine claims.

The surviving claims include challenges to State Department actions on refugee resettlement as well as other policy changes to refugee detention, fines, and related actions.

Notably, McFadden’s ruling did not dismiss a claim against Biden’s border wall policies. That sets the suit apart from a recent ruling on Arizona’s NEPA case (<a href="http://climatecasechart.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/16/case-documents/2022/20220207_docket-221-cv-00617_order-1.pdf">pdf</a>), which found that the Trump administration’s NEPA waiver for the border wall could help justify waiving NEPA analysis of a halt to border wall construction.

"It’s not necessarily a bad thing that all judges don’t see things the same way," Axelrod said.

She thinks the plaintiffs and defendants will likely both file motions for summary judgment.

"The case will proceed to litigate the merits of whether the Biden administration’s actions on immigration have had significant environmental impacts, and if those impacts have been felt by the plaintiffs in this case," Axelrod wrote in an <a href="https://cis.org/Axelrod/Court-Rules-NEPA-Lawsuit-Can-Proceed">Aug. 18 article</a> on the ruling.
<h2>Environmental Concerns Over Mass Immigration not New</h2>
The use of environmental law against changes to immigration policy is relatively novel. Yet, environmentalists have long worried about the potential impact of rapid population growth, including growth driven by mass immigration.

NEPA itself dates back to 1970, a period when overpopulation topped the list of worries for many environmentalists.

Indeed, as the Center’s suit points out, the original <a href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/STATUTE-83/pdf/STATUTE-83-Pg852.pdf">Congressional declaration of national environmental policy</a> calls population growth one of the "profound influences" driving the need for a new law.

That declaration also states that the federal government bears responsibility for "[achieving] a balance between population and resource use which will permit high standards of living and a wide sharing of life's amenities."

NEPA was passed just half a decade after an even more transformative law: the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965.

"The bill will not flood our cities with immigrants. It will not upset the ethnic mix of our society. It will not relax the standards of admission. It will not cause American workers to lose their jobs," former Sen. Edward Kennedy (D-Mass.), a major supporter of the bill, testified before an immigration subcommittee.

Yet, in the following decades, mass immigration, both legal and illegal, has driven the majority of population growth in the United States.

Demographers expect that trend to intensify. Pew Research <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/hispanic/2015/09/28/modern-immigration-wave-brings-59-million-to-u-s-driving-population-growth-and-change-through-2065/">projects</a> future immigrants and their descendants will cause 88 percent of the population increase in the U.S. between 2015 and 2065.

The Center for Immigration Studies has an even higher estimate. They <a href="https://cis.org/Report/Projecting-Impact-Immigration-US-Population">think</a> immigration will drive 95 percent of population growth by 2060.

In recent decades, however, immigration has become a third rail for environmentalists.

As recently as 1989, the Sierra Club maintained that "[i]mmigration to the U.S. should be no greater than that which will permit achievement of population stabilization in the U.S."

Mega-donor David Gelbaum may have led the Sierra Club to change its tune.

During the mid-1990s, the businessman told the group’s director that "if they ever came out anti-immigration, they would never get a dollar from me."

He later donated more than $100 million to the organization.

The group’s shift prompted some Sierrans to form a splinter organization, Sierrans for U.S. Population Stabilization (<a href="https://www.susps.org/index.html">SUSPS</a>), that opposes unchecked immigration as well as racial bigotry aimed at immigrant groups.

A SUSPS insider told The Epoch Times that multiple founding members were unaware of any efforts by the Sierra Club to use NEPA or other environmental laws against illegal immigration in earlier decades.

The Sierra Club and Department of Homeland Security did not respond to a request for comment by press time.

The Departments of Justice and State declined to comment on the lawsuit.

<em>From <a href="https://www.theepochtimes.com/lawsuit-using-environmental-law-against-biden-immigration-policies-can-proceed-judge_4708168.html">The Epoch Times</a></em>

environment

immigration

Videos

judge

04_Top Stories

lawsuit

Latest Clips

biden

Policies

Immigration &amp; Border Security

Nathan Worcester covers national politics for The Epoch Times and has also focused on energy and the environment. Nathan has written about everything from fusion energy and ESG to Biden's classified documents and international conservative politics. He lives and works in Chicago. Nathan can be reached at nathan.worcester@epochtimes.us

Nathan Worcester

Latest and breaking news, documentaries, movies, and lifestyle content on NTD+.
 
Empower your knowledge and elevate your spirit with NTD+, your go-to destination for truthful news, insightful documentaries, and captivating lifestyle content that enriches your life.

Lawsuit Using Environmental Law Against Biden Immigration Policies Can Proceed: Judge

Cary Dunst is the news anchor for NTD Evening News. He is also the co-host of NTD Good Morning.


Cary Dunst

News with integrity, from the United States and around the world. Focused reports and analyses that shed light on major issues the world deserves to know. NTD Evening News airs daily at 6 p.m. ET.

NTD Evening News

NTD Evening News Full Broadcast (July 24)

We present news that is truthful and based on facts, outside of the political fog. Instead of focusing on the negative things happening around us, our mission is to give our viewers a good morning with empathetic and uplifting stories. Our aim is to provide an antidote to negativity by shining a light on the best side of people. We speak to inspiring people who positively impact communities, pursue topics that represent our common human values, and will never miss an opportunity to bring you heartwarming stories.

NTD Good Morning

NTD Good Morning Full Broadcast (July 24)

NTD Evening News Full Broadcast (July 23)

Special Coverage

2026 Rally and March to End the Persecution of Falun Dafa

NTD Good Morning Full Broadcast (July 23)

NTD Evening News Full Broadcast (July 22)

NTD Good Morning Full Broadcast (July 22)

NTD Evening News Full Broadcast (July 21)

NTD Good Morning Full Broadcast (July 21)

NTD Evening News Full Broadcast (July 20)

NTD Good Morning Full Broadcast (July 20)

Chris Beers is an NTD News anchor and political correspondent based at the network's global headquarters in New York City. Chris co-anchors "NTD News Today" weekdays at 10:00 am ET.