Married couples can make a costly mistake by not understanding Social Security spousal benefits—especially in retirement, when every dollar counts.
1. Get Aware of Social Security Spousal Realities
The biggest challenge married couples face when deciding when to claim Social Security benefits is that they do not know how long each spouse will live.“If they had this information, deciding when to claim benefits would be a simple decision,” Robert Steinberg, founder and CEO at Blue Chip Partners in Farmington Hills, Mich., told NTD News.
2. Married Couples' Plan Should Start Early
The spousal blueprint is actually simple. Determine which spouse receives the larger benefit, and have that spouse wait as long as they can (ideally until 70) while the lower earner claims as early as possible for cash flow.“That's because the benefit amount depends on the amount that the higher earner receives, and the surviving spouse receives that benefit for many years,” Josh Katz, CPA and founder of Universal Tax Professionals, told NTD.
Katz said he’s seen too many couples take the higher check early so they can have it, but then the surviving spouse gets the lower check for the rest of their lives. “That's an error that can't be corrected,” he said. “That higher benefit is guaranteed for life, and it accrues 8 percent per year for each year the benefit is postponed, up to three years after full retirement age.”
The so-called "split" strategy works best for most of his clients, Katz noted. “The higher earner waits to age 70, while the lower earner begins at 62 or full retirement age,” he said. “The lower earner starts at 62 or full retirement age, and the higher earner waits until age 70. That means couples are getting income now and the big cash sum continues to grow.”
3. Leverage These Survivorship Tips When a Spouse Passes On
A well-planned Social Security spousal survivorship plan is also a high priority for married couples.“I wish more couples thought about it before they filed,” Kaylee McClellan, a financial advisor at Minnesota-based Innovative Planning, told NTD. “When one spouse passes away, the survivor doesn't keep both checks; they step up to whichever of the two benefits is higher, and the other one goes away.”
That scenario means the age at which the higher earner files isn't just a decision about their own retirement income; it's a decision about what their spouse will have to live on, potentially for decades, after they're gone.
Think of it as insurance for whoever outlives whom, McClellan said. “If the higher earner can afford to delay filing, every year they wait locks in a larger check for their own household now, and a larger safety net for their spouse later.”
Don’t Make These Spousal Benefits Mistakes When Taking Social Security
The number one mistake spouses make with Social Security is filing early just because you can, without running the actual numbers. “I get the instinct,” McClellan said. “It's your money, so why not take it?But filing early doesn't just reduce your own check. “If you're the higher earner, it can permanently shrink the benefit your spouse would eventually inherit as a survivor, which is a decision that outlives you,” she noted.
A big second mistake is not accounting for taxes. “Depending on your combined income, a portion of your Social Security benefit may be taxable, and couples are often surprised by that the first year they file,” McClellan added.
