Advance Auto Parts’ Lukewarm Q4 Results Disappoint Investors Amid Restructuring

Published: 2/27/2025, 11:51:16 PM EST
Advance Auto Parts’ Lukewarm Q4 Results Disappoint Investors Amid Restructuring
An Advance Auto Parts location in Takoma Park, Md., on Aug. 22, 2024. (Tierney L. Cross/Getty Images)

Investors responded negatively after Advance Auto Parts said it was on track to reach its 2027 goals during a fourth-quarter earnings call on Wednesday.

The aftermarket automotive parts provider announced a restructuring plan in November 2024, which included the closure of around 700 stores and four distribution centers.

“We ended 2024 with a healthy balance sheet,” Advance Auto Parts President and CEO Shane O'Kelly said in a news release.

O’Kelly said the company brought talented executives on board and was focusing hard on providing faster access to auto parts for all of its customers across its network.

After selling auto parts distributor Worldpac to Carlyle Group for $1.5 billion in August last year, the company decided to close approximately 500 of its 4,788 corporate stores and leave 200 of its 934 independently owned Carquest branded stores.

Advance Auto Parts said it also intended to shut down four distribution centers with the goal of merging its remaining centers into 12 large facilities by the end of 2026.

The restructuring plan also involves launching 60 smaller market hub locations by mid-2027, optimizing transportation routes, improving distribution speed, and increasing the speed of opening new stores, the company said.

“We remain committed to delivering an improved operating performance in 2025 and making progress toward our FY27 goal of achieving an adjusted operating margin of approximately 7 percent,” O’Kelly said.

Despite full-year net sales slightly topping corporate predictions at $9.1 billion, Advance shares dropped dramatically by roughly 16 percent later in the day.
The company reported a negative cash flow of $40 million—less than half of 2023’s $84 million, but what likely discouraged investors was an anticipated negative cash flow of 25 to 85 million for 2025.

Q4 earnings were down 0.9 percent from last year, owing to a re-evaluation of existing stock value and disappointing liquidation sales at closing locations.

The company also said it had closed 40 stores and opened 42 new ones in 2024.

Though Advance did not provide a complete list of stores up for closure, 24 of its locations across 14 states are up for sale through real estate company Hilco.

The stores are located in major metro areas in Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Florida, Georgia, Kansas, Louisiana, Michigan, Mississippi, North Carolina, Texas, Washington, and Wisconsin.

Notable cities include Corpus Christy, Fort Myers, McAllen, Mesa, New Orleans, and Phoenix.

Buyers have time until March 13 to place their bids for these properties.

When Advance announced its restructuring, it cited lower consumer spending—likely due to inflationary headwinds—hurricanes, and the Crowdstrike outage, when a faulty software update paralyzed more than 1 billion Windows-based computer systems across the globe.

Advance Auto Parts is headquartered in Raleigh, North Carolina, and has stores in the United States, Canada, Puerto Rico, and the U.S. Virgin Islands.