21-Year-Old UMass Lowell Soccer Goalkeeper Killed in Ohio Highway Crash

A college soccer goalkeeper whose journey took him through three programs before landing at UMass Lowell died early Sunday morning after a fatal highway crash in his home state of Ohio.
Published: 7/6/2026, 10:50:25 PM EDT
21-Year-Old UMass Lowell Soccer Goalkeeper Killed in Ohio Highway Crash
Police tape in a stock photo. (Carl Ballou/Shutterstock)

A college soccer goalkeeper whose journey took him through three programs before landing at UMass Lowell died early Sunday morning after a fatal highway crash in his home state of Ohio.

Tobias "Toby" Forsythe, 21, of Gahanna, Ohio, died on the scene of a crash that occurred just after 1:30 a.m. on Interstate 71 in Madison County, the Ohio State Highway Patrol said in a statement to local outlet WSYX News.

NTD contacted the highway patrol for comment but did not hear back before publication time.

Authorities said a Freightliner driven by Bekhzod Asrarov, 42, was traveling southbound on I-71 at mile marker 82 when it struck Forsythe's 2025 Honda Accord. The Ohio State Highway Patrol is continuing to investigate the crash.

The six-foot-one goalkeeper had carved out an extensive collegiate soccer career before his death. Ashland University Men's Soccer wrote on Facebook Sunday that Forsythe attended, and played for the Eagles from 2023 to 2025 after graduating from Gahanna Lincoln High School in Columbus.
UMass Lowell Athletics, in an announcement of their own on Monday, said he later transferred to Shawnee State University, where he started all 17 games during the 2025 season. He had most recently joined the River Hawks for the 2026 spring season. Beyond college soccer, Forsythe also represented Columbus Astray in the United Premier Soccer League.

Off the field, Forsythe was an economics major enrolled in UMass Lowell's College of Fine Arts, Humanities, and Social Sciences.

UMass Lowell Director of Athletics Lynn Coutts expressed grief on behalf of the entire department on Monday.

"Our entire athletics department is heartbroken by Toby's passing," UMass Lowell Director of Athletics Lynn Coutts said in the announcement. "Although Toby's time as a River Hawk was cut far too short, he left a meaningful impact and will always be remembered as a cherished member of our UMass Lowell family."

Men's soccer Head Coach Kyle Zenoni reflected on Forsythe's character and work ethic.

"Toby was everything you hope for in a student-athlete and an even better person," Zenoni said. "He was humble, honest, selfless and the definition of hard work. Every single day, he showed up ready to compete, improve and do whatever was asked of him."

Shawnee State Men's Soccer remembered Forsythe in a Sunday Instagram post as a competitor who demanded the best from those around him. "You had a fire in you that could not be ignored," the program wrote. "You challenged us, believed in us, and made us better, even when we did not want to hear it."
Columbus Astray similarly mourned the loss of a player they described as "a cherished member of our community, dedicated athlete, and persistently kind-hearted friend,” in their own post on Instagram.

According to UMass Lowell Athletics, counseling services are being made available to student-athletes and staff. Funeral arrangements had not been completed as of Monday and will be announced by the Forsythe family at a later date.