Tommy DeCarlo, the singer who rose from a karaoke performer in a North Carolina bowling alley to become the lead vocalist of the legendary rock band Boston, died Monday after a months-long battle with brain cancer. He was 60.
His children—Annie, Talia, and Tommy Jr.—confirmed his death in a statement posted to his social media accounts.
"Everyone who has heard Tommy sing on stage, or on BOSTON albums, knows what a gifted artist he was, but few know how hard he worked to fill that role of BOSTON's lead vocalist, and to turn himself into a top-tier live performer—or more important, what a dedicated father he was to his children," Scholz wrote.
His musical journey began far more quietly. DeCarlo joined his school choir in elementary school but was repeatedly passed over for solo parts. "They always told me my voice was too soft," he recalled. He taught himself piano around age 14, and it was the music of Boston—and the voice of original lead singer Brad Delp—that ultimately shaped his vocal ability. "It wasn't like I was trying to sing like Brad, it was just that I loved to sing along with him," DeCarlo explained on the band's website.
After spending 18 years in Florida, DeCarlo relocated his family to Charlotte, North Carolina, in 2005. He lived what he described as a relatively normal life, devoted to his wife and children, and played in a local cover band with his son, a guitarist.
DeCarlo's extraordinary rise to rock stardom began online. He had posted covers of Boston songs—along with an original tribute to the late Delp—on his MySpace page. When word of a planned tribute concert reached him, a friend urged him to reach out to the band. DeCarlo sent his page to what he called "the BOSTON camp" and offered to perform his tribute song, never expecting a reply. He received a polite response weeks later declining additional performers.
But fate intervened. Scholz stumbled upon DeCarlo's cover of "Don't Look Back" and was stunned by what he heard. According to the band's website, Scholz declared: "I haven't heard anyone else sing like that in 35 years."
Scholz invited DeCarlo to sing at the tribute show. Before that night, the largest audience DeCarlo had ever performed for was a few dozen people at a bowling alley—most of whom, he joked, were actually bowling. His next performance was before more than 5,000 fans.
"I walked through the doors and could not believe it … there was BOSTON rehearsing 'Don't Look Back.' Wow!" DeCarlo recalled. After singing "Smokin'" at rehearsal, Scholz walked over and gave him a high-five. "I was like, 'No way that just happened!'" he said.
He went on to serve as Boston's lead vocalist for roughly a decade.
Scholz remembered DeCarlo as "a competitive athlete, and yet a gentle soul" who was cherished by his son and many others as "a sweet man who did not deserve to be cut down at such a young age."
"It's not surprising that one of his favorite BOSTON songs to sing was 'To Be a Man,'" Scholz wrote. "Rest in peace Tommy, you did know what it took to be a man."
